Issuing shares and the share register
November 17, 202624 min read
The articles authorize shares. They do not hand those shares to the founders. Issuing a share is the act that creates a shareholder. Until that act is recorded, the people who paid for the incorporation may believe they own the company and still have nothing in the register to prove it.
A share is a bundle of rights described in the articles: typically a vote, a chance to receive dividends if the directors declare them, and a share of what remains if the company is dissolved. The number of shares a person holds is how those rights are divided. Percentage talk, “we are fifty-fifty,” has to be turned into a number of shares of a named class.
Issue the shares at the beginning, in the amounts the founders agreed, and record the consideration. Waiting until a dispute, a financing, or a sale forces the company to invent a history. Invented history is where ownership fights start.
What an issuance looks like
Directors resolve to issue a stated number of shares of a stated class to a stated person, for a stated price or other consideration. The person becomes a shareholder when the shares are issued in accordance with that resolution and the statute, and when the register records it. Payment into the company’s bank account, once the account exists, should match the consideration the resolution describes.
Consideration can be money. It can, in proper cases, be property or past services, subject to the rules on how shares may be paid for. A promise of future work is a weak and often invalid basis for an issuance. If the founders’ real deal is that one person will work and the other will pay, write that deal in a way that can actually support the shares, and get advice before you rely on it.
Do not issue shares the articles do not authorize. If you need a new class, amend the articles first. Issuing “preferred” shares from a company whose articles create only common shares does not create a preferred class. It creates a confused register.
The share register
The register is the official list of shareholders. It shows the name and address of each holder, the class, the number of shares, and the date they were issued or transferred. It is kept with the other corporate records. A cap table in a spreadsheet can be useful as a working copy. It is not the register unless the company treats that file, deliberately, as the register and keeps it with the minute book.
Transfers are entered when they happen, not when someone remembers at year end. A transfer that is not recorded leaves the register showing the old owner. The company takes directions from the registered holder. The person who “really” bought the shares, and never got recorded, is in a poor position.
Share certificates are optional for many private companies if the articles and the statute allow uncertificated shares. If you do issue certificates, they should match the register, be signed by the officers the by-laws name, and be cancelled when the shares are transferred. An uncancelled certificate in a drawer is how a buyer gets two stories about the same shares.
Ownership is the register, plus the articles
Two documents answer “who owns this company?” The articles say which classes exist and what they may do. The register says who holds them. A shareholders’ agreement can add promises among the owners, such as a right of first refusal. The agreement does not replace the register. If they conflict, you have a problem to fix, not a choice of which document you prefer that day.
Equal owners should be able to see equal numbers, or an unequal number that they understand and agreed to, on the register. A 51/49 split that was filed as 50/50, or the reverse, will not be saved by a text message. Correct the register only by a real issuance or a real transfer, recorded properly.
When a new person joins, issue or transfer shares on purpose. Adding their name to the website is not an issuance. Neither is reimbursing them for an expense. The register changes when the company issues or transfers shares, and not before.
When the numbers have to be shown
Banks, investors, and buyers ask who owns the company. The answer is the register, supported by the resolutions that issued or transferred the shares, and by evidence of the consideration if money was supposed to change hands. A slide that shows percentages is a summary. It should be prepared from the register, and it should be thrown away if it disagrees with the register.
If you discover a gap, such as shares everyone thought were issued and a register that is blank, stop and repair it with a proper issuance dated when the decision is actually made, or with advice on whether a late record of an earlier issuance is supportable. Do not backdate signatures to a day nobody signed. A clean late issuance is safer than a tidy fiction.
Keep the register current enough that you could print it this afternoon. That standard, more than any particular template, is what makes a small federal corporation saleable and bankable. The articles built the shelves. The register says what is on them.
This article is general information about federal incorporation in Canada. It is not legal, tax, or accounting advice.